I went the other direction and started with woodies, now shooting carbon. I can switch back and forth though because at close ranges 0-20yrd. they have the same point of impact
.
As far as grains per pound......obviously the carbons are much lighter than the woodies.
I dropped from close to 11 grains per pound with woodies to around 8 GPP with carbons, both shoot great but I'm leaning more toward the "Straight or Broke" choice with the carbons.
I'm not really sure yet and I'll have to give them a little time before I make up my mind completely about that.
I could have added weights to the carbons, but they shoot so good the way they are, that I don't see the need to.
The carbons are definitely much easier to make, no sanding, spining, then sanding some more, then finishing, and finally fletching. With carbons just fletch and then tune with different wt. points to see which work best.......as long as you start with a spine that's close to what your bow needs.
I would like to mention that by starting out with wood shafts, I learned a great deal about arrow spine and how it affects accuracy. That's something that I would recommend everybody who is new to traditional archery fully understand because it will help you in the long run. It's just not as simple as picking up a handful of arrows at Walmart, slapping some broadheads on them and going hunting.....expecting perfect arrow flight, that's just not going to happen.
I would suggest that you don't go overboard and buy a dozen of either shaft choice right off the bat. Just get enough to test and see what you are comfortable with, then you could always refine your search later and buy more when you find what you like. That way they don't end up in the classified ads section and you take a beating on them.
As a matter of fact, there's nothing in the world wrong with shooting used carbons as long as they are from a trusted source. If they are in good sound shape, not cracked or abused then you could get lots of life out of them.
Generally, you should be able to find some good used ones if you shop around a little bit.