I bet your too stiff on the arrow. I assume you have them cut down somewhere around 28 to 29 inches.
I used to shoot a 62 lb recurve with 2117 arrows that were cut at 31 and 1/2 inches. I also had at least 175 grains of point weight also. It shoot perfectly with no feathers.
If you want to shoot aluminum with that short of a draw on a longbow at 59# try this.
Start with a 2016 arrow shaft 31"inches in length with your desired weight of field point at least 125 grains, (the weight that matches your broad head).
NO feathers allowed!! Stand about 10 yds from your target. Your a lefty so if the arrow darts off to the left, and I think it will,the arrow is too weak.
Start shortening the arrow length 1/4 to 1/2 inch at a time until the arrow flies right down the middle and strikes the target on a relativly straight line.
If at any time the arrow darts of to the right, your shaft has gotten shortened too much and got too stiff. In this case you can add point weight to make the arrow spine weaker causing the arrow to fly back more to the left and hopefully be right down the middle.
If you are convinced that you must shoot a 2117, you will have to cut your arrows nearly full length and have considerable point weight to get it weak enough to be shot straight without feathers. The matter is morse the further from center shot your bow is.
Keep at it................good luck!