I vote for the Maddog as well. My boy just won a Maddog Pup and he should be able to shoot it for a few years then it will be handed down to the next in need here on T-Gang. Call Mike at Maddog he will steer you in the right direction. The 5 year old will probably have to fight a larger bow I would think till she grows a year or two if you want something that can actually spit an arrow out there. Maybe not, I'm not sure of her size , so call Mike tell him the situation, see what he says. Good luck Chris