I live in Michigan, and actually, I live in the area of the northern lower penninsula where the "bait ban" is still in place.
I began my bowhunting career perched in a tree, "guarding" a pile of bait of all sorts.
It was they way everyone "bowhunted". Even as a dumb kid, I learned early that bait piles were NOT everything they were cracked up to be. Deer that experience even moderate hunting pressure at baitpiles react to it by avoiding them during good daylight. I learned early on, that seeing deer show up to eat at a baitpile in the last couple minutes of legal shooting light, OR even AFTER legal time was NOT the best of situations.
Baiting on a large scale as was/IS commonplace on large chunks of private land can and will change deer movements...baiting with two gallons of corn spread out will do less altering of deer movements than a foodplot...IMHO.
Personally, I don`t care if a person baits deer with corn or other foods. I don`t haul bait into the woods anymore...and haven`t for years. I DO consider an alfalfa field with worn trails leading to it a "baitpile"...along with a producing oak, or apple tree(s).(or any other natural food source) A cornfield can be a bedding area...but to me, it is a large baitpile that I don`t have to carry. Honestly, a very well kept secret is there is alot less effort into QUALITY scouting, than hauling bait. PLUS, it is MUCH more ENJOYABLE!!!
Nobody can argue about how baiting LOOKS to the non-hunting public. This fact alone makes me think baiting is bad for hunting. I KNOW it is just another way to hunt, and I cannot see much difference between a good seasonal food source and a hauled in baitpile. We are taking advantage of the deer`s need for food.
I also don`t believe baiting "ruined" hunting in Michigan, BUT I DO BELIEVE that much of the behavior and attitudes hunters developed through the OVERUSE of bait DID indeed cause damage to hunting in Michigan.
BTW...the "bait ban" we speak of is just a myth. AT BEST, baiting was reduced during the "ban".
If ANYONE who lives in Michigan can name ONE problem the bait ban solved, I would sure like to hear it.