Hard to argue that there is anything better than a carbon arrow. Lots of folks like wood arrows because they are more traditional, but IMO there is nothing that will beat the straightness, durability, and consistency of carbon. Ordinarily for your weight bow I would say you would need a Beman or Easton 500, GT 35/55, or Carbon Express 150. However you stated you might go as high as 250gr up front, so you may need a 400, 55/75, or, 250 in those shafts. They all offer a woodgrain shaft (Beman MFX Classic, GT Traditional, CX Heritage) which look really good IMO and add more weight. Carbon shafts (in my experience) respond more to length changes than point weight, so you might want to try some different lenghts as well as playing with point weight.