I'm glad Dave posted something about this encounter. I was the one who said "stop calling" and I can tell you guys, up until that time I "thought" that I had never called in a cat. Now, I'm almost certain that I have before. This big tom came in so quiet and so smooth, it was amazing...Like Dave said, he never saw him- but after the cat left we went over to the tracks and he was actually much closer to Dave than he was me. At first I just saw his back and thought it might be a elk calf, it was just surreal to see that huge cat at full stealth coming in on your buddy who's calling for you. I didn't have a tag either but he was a perfect 25 yards broadside and was so intent on the caller (Dave) that he never saw me until I called out. I've been treed by bears and charged by water buffalo but I have never been any more rattled than seeing that cat hunting at close range.