Nothing beats the convenience of a glove for hunting imo. I used a glove for years but struggled when my fingers started to crack and bleed like they always do in the fall. I would just shoot through the pain or forgo practice, neither a good thing.
This summer I learned how to shoot a tab when I developed an early and painful split on my index finger. I shoot split and the Cavalier tab with a spacer eliminated the pain. Took a while to get used to the tab, now my old glove feels very uncomfortable. I know the Cavalier will not be as convenient this fall, but at least I will be pain free and able to practice.