Difficult to say, different angles, but I'd say it could definately be 2 different deer. One rack looks a little more "square" to me while the other looks more rounded. The shape and angles of the brows look a little different too. Maybe it's just the angles playing tricks with my eyes or maybe you've got you a set of twins. Either way, I'd have a hard time passing on either of them. Of course I'm a public land guy, which normaly means if it's legal, I'm throwin' an arrow at it.