A good glove is the one personal archery item that isn't going to be right for anyone but you. There are some gloves of amazing quality out there that just don't work for me, but I wish they did. All these factors come into play:
*Whether you shoot split or 3-under,
*Whether you like to "feel" the string
*How deep you hook
*Proximity of your fingers to each that feels natural and that it allows
*Construction of the finger stalls, i.e are there bulky seams that interfere with your anchor, etc.
*Sensitivity of your fingertips after a lot of shooting
I feel your pain. WallyWorld used to offer a "plainjane" glove by Fieldline and close them out at $5 after hunting season. Wish I'd bought them out! Closest I've been able to come since is the Classic at Kustom King.