There are advantages and disadvantages, Years ago I purchased a bow from Dan Quillan when I was stationed at Benning. He suggested a full length 23/64 arrow...it flew well and killed well. Now I shoot a cedar tapered arrow...I like the flight I get from those (I think my release is a bit cleaner with the smaller knock) and they kill well. I will say arrow flight is way way more important than a typical hunter new to the sport may realize...flight has to be super sweet to get good penetration. I like many trad archers learned that the hard way over the years. Therefor, whatever gives you the best arrow flight is the answer.