Which Backquiver?

[Kilryth]

This is my first Backquiver for hunting, and I'm not 100% sure what I'm looking for.  I know I want something durable, something that stays in place on my back, has a large pocket for accessories, and something that holds plenty of arrows for target practice.  I'm not too concerned about NOISE or a solid bottom because I can add my own liners, fillers, tubes, etc.

I also prefer that it not be a home-made looking quiver, as I plan to make my own sometime in the future when I have more spare time.  

Any suggestions?  These are the 3 that I'm deciding between:

Legacy Leather Olympus leather quiver -  http://www.*********archery.com/legacy-leather-olympus-back-quiver.html

Legacy Leather Omega Suede quiver -  http://www.*********archery.com/legacy-leather-omega-back-quiver.html

Vista Honcho "Split Grain Leather" quiver -  http://www.cabelas.com/quivers-honcho-leather-back-quiver-1.shtml   I think this is suede too, since suede is made from split-grain and it looks like the Omega.

Does anyone have experience with any of these quivers?  At initial look, the Olympus appears to meet my desired features best, but I don't know what type of leather is used (and whether it is a good weight for back quivers)

[ChrisM]

None of the above.  If you want a real hunting quiver, one that forms to you and holds the arrows secure and quiet get one from howard hill archery.  They are a sponcer here and there quiver is made right.  The common mistake is a quiver that is too stiff or does not hang right.

[Kilryth]

Thanks for the feedback, Chris.  Wouldn't the adjustable Y-strap allow the quiver to hang correctly?  It seems like it would provide a better fit from person-to-person than a single leather strap.

Or do you mean that the leather is too light/thin to maintain its shape?  I can definitely see how the heavier cowhide quiver holds its shape better..

What ounce cowhide do you recommend to made a solid, but form-fitting quiver?

[58WINTERS]

Chris is right if you are looking for a hunting quiver. The y strap configuration is a disadvantage as it does not allow you to shift the quiver under your arm in tight quarters.  It also positions the quiver vertically on you back which also contributes to difficulties in the field. large pocket is a no no throws the quiver off balance. the quiver needs to form to you and lay in the correct position across your back and off your shoulder. When properly designed it will become a part of you this is why correct strap placement is very important. What you have in mind is a back pack with a place for arrows and will not work well in actual hunting situations. Take a good look at the Howard Hill.  Steven Catts "hide handler" also makes a Hill style that is very good I would get it without the pocket  however.
58

[ChrisM]

Howard hill was the master of the back quiver.  Look up some vids of him shooting and pay attention to his quiver to see what one should fit like.

[slowbowjoe]

Take a look at what Mike's Archery Leather (sponsor here) has to offer... looks like a nice, functional, quality made back quiver at an affordable price. Mike uses these himself, I'd trust he knows what works.

[petalumapete]

I would suggest alpine wool and leather. The owner Rudy will bend over backwards to make you exactly what you want.
 He makes his quivers from full thickness buffalo. The leather is butter soft will conform to your back but is tuff as nails. I had him make mine plus my arm guard and couldn't be more pleased.
 His customer service is top notch, as a matter of fact he contacted me 6 months after I had my quiver to make sure it was working for me. He also asked for feedback of any improvements I could think of.
I ask you. Have you ever bought enything and had the company call 6 months later to make sure you were happy?
I'm not a fan guy or a add for him. Just a very satisfied customer.
You can find him on his web site
Alpinw wool and leather

[Richie]

Mikes Archery Leather X 2 , My son and I both use his quivers , they are awesome.

[30coupe]

I wouldn't use any of the ones you list. I have tried one like that and they are a pain in the butt. A Hill style quiver is designed for hunting. HH Archery does offer them, Sunset Hill (Nate Steen) is a member here and makes as fine a Hill style hunting quiver as you will find. He will also make a kit if you want to assemble your own. I have one on the way. Mine will be like the one on the left:

 

He also includes a string pouch. I would caution you not to overload it. As has been said, it will throw the balance of the quiver off.

I know this because this was my first attempt at a quiver build:

 

The pouch is too big for one thing, so I tended to put too much crap in it. This quiver is workable, but the leather is a bit too soft and I want a larger quiver for hunting.

Hope this helps you learn from my experience/mistakes.