I am primarily a small game hunter. My favorite heads for small game are the RFA Talons. They are tough as nails, the tips are sharp enough to prevent glancing and the cup makes for a ton of blunt force trauma. The pyramidal shape keeps them from sticking too bad into trees and stumps. They are phenominal.
Another favorite is a Judo point for areas where I'm concerned I might loose an arrow. I typically carry either 2 Judo and 2 Talon tipped arrows or 2 Judo and 3 Talon arrows for small game hunting.
The Judo doesn't work as well on game than the Talon but really helps with arrow recovery. I actually like the Talons for small game hunting and Judo points for stumping so much that I specifically build all of my arrows to take 125gr screw in points just so I can use them. Because I wanted more weight for hogs and deer, I now build them up with footings and 100gr inserts, but I wont consider any other point weight.