GT 5575s are .400 spine. His setup is pretty close to yours, JB. The only thing is, he's showing really weak. 6" off at 15 yards is a lot. Normally you'd need to take off more than 100 grains of point weight to move an impact point that much. He can't do that with his current 50 gr insert/ 125 gr point combination. He also already has his arrows cut about as short as he can go. Going back to an aluminum insert won't stiffen them up near enough.
The only option, if that 5575 setup is indeed too weak, is to go to a 7595. I can't imagine that bow shoots hard enough for that. Heck, that's what I shoot out of a 65@31" d/r bow. And even then, I need 200 grains up front.
So, I'm guessing there's something else going on. By putting a heavy point on his existing arrows, theoretically, that should move the impact point of his bare shafts further to the right.