Not picking a spot or not remembering picking a spot, I assume you practice and what you practice becomes habit if practicing the motion enough.
Look guys, I hear on Trad Gang all the time, I messed up, I wounded a deer, I had a clean miss, and my shot didn't hit where I was looking. One guy said he was going back to compound not long ago. All of the complaints are valid and some people should go back to shooting a compound. If you are not committed to becoming better at what we do every day this sport is not for you. I know from what I’m hearing from most of the guys on here that picking a spot is most likely not the problem. Remembering picking a spot could be, but there are so many practiced points of contact, muscle memory, how your body is positioned the perfect “T”. When you practice the shooting of a recurve or longbow over and over, it is then no longer a practiced motion but a habit, and then it becomes instinct. So there are three levels to be learned, I’m sure there are more that I am not picking up on. One is “Practice” Two is “Habit” and then three is “Instinct” most people think because we call ourselves instinctive shooters that, that automatically makes that statement true, and in some ways it is. Think of it as we are in training when we first start shooting instinctive oh wait a minute we are.
Then we practice and it becomes a habit and that is where most of us are now unless you want to put yourselves in the same category as Howard Hill, Fred Bear, Paul Schafer just to mention a few. Now these guys had mastered the art of shooting a bow, watch the videos here on the Gang and you will see what I am referring to. Shooting jack rabbits running across the desert at forty yards or shooting a running animal running down the side of a mountain at over seventy yards, that is true instinctive shooting. Come on guys do you think these guys remember picking a spot? They practiced or I should say lived shooting a bow.
The biggest problem I have reading some of the post here on Trad Gang is when a guy starts shooting a recurve or longbow and they can’t understand why they are not putting the arrow in the same spot they did with a compound, “Come On Man” one, after a year of shooting you are still in the practice state of learning and you should not expect to shoot like someone that has been shooting for years, driving to shoot like that yes but do not expect it.
I hope this is helpful to some knew archers trying to be the best instinctive shooters that they can become.
If anyone has some advise or a comment that would be helpful to new people getting into or back into traditional archery please put in your advise.