kunner, you are pulling that bow past the stacking point. Even though the bow is a good length for you, at your current draw length, pulling a bow into the stacking point is not going to help w/consistency. Nor would trying to get a blunt tipped wood arrow to fly "just" like a broadhead.
Just for grins, try a shot like this: Without preconceived notion, and, a relaxed mind and without though, swing the bow up and draw as you point the whole arrow at the target, allow your bodies natural motion to happen, and as soon as you feel the corner of your mouth, pull through there slightly and as you point your fingers at the target for a release. Take a vid of that cool, casual, enjoyably shooting style/session. Be confident not cocky.