I didn't bring up the three under/split finger & gap shooting/instinctive for any type of debate which we all know can get pretty inflamed...that's a topic for the shooter's forum for sure....
This is just food for thought as to how it pertains to shooting Semi-Longbows to get us to think about why we do certain things....My opinion is that because of the popularity of 3d or target shooting the last 40 years, and the fact that the majority of traditional shooters are shooting in somewhat confined areas, much emphasis has been placed on grouping arrows into targets. We feel pressure if we do not or are not able to group arrows at reasonable ranges, so we limit our shooting distances and/or we begin using a referrance point (like the arrow or tip) to help us aim...in order to group arrows. This is all done to get quick success or immediate satisfaction in our accuracy requirements. Gone are the days when the majority of archers/bowhunters shot completely by "feel" or "instinctive". Why?
"instinctive" shooting (term used for not using a referrence point in aiming) requires time to master, or to be sufficiently proficient for hunting. As a society today, we do not want to wait to be proficient. We want accuracy now. Back in the day, archery was a pastime for life and archers took a more laid back approach and learned over years to be a good shot. I bring this up because we all, all of us shooters, are capable of shooting very accurately by not seeing any referrence point for aiming. We practice this very method every day without realizing it. Every day we get into our vehicles and 'aim' them on the road without looking down or consciously 'seeing' the dash/steering wheel/hood. How do we aim them? by seeing the vehicle in our subconscious vision in relation to our surroundings and the brain adjusts and tells our hands how to operate the steering wheel. The only time we see the dash is if we make a conscious effort to look at it. This 'aiming' would be more difficult if we sat on the hood without any reference points for our instinctive vision to see subconsciously.
That is a good way to explain instinctive shooting. We do not need any conscious effort of looking at an arrow point at any part of the shooting in order to be accurate. Our brains, subconscious aiming, hand-eye coordination and feel will take care of the aiming. We just have to get ourselves out of the way. We won't be a good shot when we start. that's part of the learning process. Just like we got nervous when we were 16, learning to drive a car and having to thread the car (aim) between semitrucks on the highway at 65 mph. but we learned, and now we drive without conscious thought. Why do we make instinctive shooting any more difficult on ourselves?
Shooting a longbow like the old masters....Pope, Young, Hill, Stevenson, Schulz, and a host of others, means a gradual shift to instinctive shooting by repetition. Relying on not seeing the arrow during the shot. This way of shooting completely frees up the shooter to be able to shoot moving targets, quick or hurried shot situations, low light conditions (not meaning at dark) or basically being able to shoot in whatever shot situation happens in the woods....instead of the modern method of 'setting up' the shot situation so that there is 'our control' of the shot, so we feel we will be accurate. We don't 'set up' our driving/aiming of a car situations, we just react and aim and drive according to the scenario in front of us. Learning to shoot the same way will free us up and lessen the pressure we feel to be accurate. We will be accurate because the body knows we want to be and it will adjust our aiming to put the arrow in the target. We might not be able to stack/group arrows in tight bunches, but we will be able to hit the kill zone on a crisp morning hunt, with the breeze blowing, the deer moving, our breathing heavy, and 3 seconds to pull it all together.
after all, isn't that what the longbow has been about for all these centuries?