More grains = better Arrow flight?

[OkieBowHunter11]

Hey guys and gals just wanted to point out that since I've switched to 145 field points my GT 600's are flying tons better out of my bear grizzly 45# I was shooting a 125 point but seems like the flight was a little erratic here and there. I recently purchased some zwickey 150 grain heads and figured I needed to go with a close match gn to get the feel. Any explanations as to why all of a sudden my groups have tightened up with the 145 points and fly better I'm pleased with the results but was curious about the science behind what happened.

[Mike Mongelli]

Uh, maybe because you got the spine closer to being correct???

[OkieBowHunter11]

I have 600 GT Trads 100 grain brass inserts total Arrow weight is coming in around 510 grains with the 145 points

[eidsvolling]

The science behind moving the balance point forward on an arrow has been available for more than ten years:   Understanding and Applying FOC  by Dr. Ed Ashby.

ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL, moving the balance point forward will improve flight and thus penetration. It's the failure to change only a single variable (in this case the distribution of total weight along the length of the arrow) that gives rise to a lot of the misunderstanding and hoo-hah that pops up concerning this aspect of the Ashby studies.

In this case, you would need to build arrows with slightly different spines in order to isolate the effect of moving the balance point forward by using a heavier point. Or you could just keep on shooting what works (better) for you.    

[Michael Arnette]

I do think heavier arrows are inherently more stable possibly because they are traveling slower and less affected by the air. But as others have mentioned it may be that these have your heads are getting your closer in spine to where you need to be.

[OkieBowHunter11]

Thanks for the helpful info understanding the reason behind it thanks again

[COMPOUNDLESS IN CONCRETE]

Sounds to me like You got the dynamic spine closer to where it needs to be with the heavier head.

[Orion]

It's not just the heavier weight, it's where you put the weight.  As others have noted, adding point weight decreased the dynamic spine and brought the arrow in closer tune to your bow.

[McDave]

The science behind what happened could be illustrated if you would shoot bare shafts with the two different points, and see which flew straighter.  By comparing the angles the bare shafts made with the target, you would have an objective measurement of which combination was better tuned for your bow, as opposed to a subjective feeling that one combination was working better than another.

[J. Holden]

I'm just happy to hear that you found something that works for you.  It's always fun when it comes together.

-Jeremy  

Because your arrows were not tuned well with the 125gr points, but apparently are tuned better with the 145gr points!

Bisch

[Fattony77]

OkieBowHunter11,
Where in OK are you? There might be someone near you that could meet with you in-person and help you out with whatever questions you may have...
Just a thought.

And I aree with what most of these guys are saying, in that, you are probably tuned a little better with that point/shaft combination than you were with the lighter point. Glad that it's working better for you.

-Tony

[Michael Arnette]

Yessir as tony said hit either of us up if you ever want help in person!

[OkieBowHunter11]

Originally posted by Fattony77:
OkieBowHunter11,
Where in OK are you? There might be someone near you that could meet with you in-person and help you out with whatever questions you may have...
Just a thought.

And I aree with what most of these guys are saying, in that, you are probably tuned a little better with that point/shaft combination than you were with the lighter point. Glad that it's working better for you.
I'm here in muskogee Tony I work through the week and I'm free on the weekend there is a unmarked 3d shoot in wagoner coming up this month I believe the weekend of the 17th of may would love to meet you guys anytime for sure and thanks
-Tony

[SKITCH]

Holy cow....you guys are neighbors.  Tony is good people!!

[Fattony77]

Sending you a PM, Okie.

Thanks, Skitch. I wish you were still around here, bud.

[Terry Green]

No, more grains does not always equal better arrow flight , if that were the case we would all have bowling balls on the end of our arrows which is ridiculous.

I don't care who's study you read (lots of folks have their own studied that are  unpublished studies) it may help in your situation but others it may not.... more grains again does not equal better arrow flight as  I replied. End of story and I'm not a doctor and neither is .....

[buckeye-mike]

[buckeye-mike]

Sorry for screwing up first post.
I also have a Bear grizzly 45#. A friend helped me tune it wit GT 1535. Ended up with the aluminum inserts and 175 grain field points. The grizzly shoots them pretty fast and straight. I put on my Simmons broadhead 175 gr Shot just as good. I used those same arrows in my bear Montana 50#, and they shot just as straight.

[AZ_Longbow]

Tune the arrow to the bow to the shooter. I personally like heavy foc arrows in the 10gpp range. It's all about the tune.