Feather rests work great. I used them quite a bit.
Then one day I put on one of those ugly, self stick Bear weather rests on a 1970's Bear because that's what they used then and I just wanted to try it. They are now my new favorite. They are as vintage as vintage gets - and they provide very consistent result for me. They are also more quiet on the draw than the feather rest. I can hear the arrow rubbing against the feather on the draw of a feather rest, but the weather rest is silent.
No, I don't spray water repellant on them either LOL!!
I am not knocking feather rests at all. Just sharing my progression from them to the sometimes frowned on weather rests.
TRAP feather rests are awesome though, and they just look "right" on a late 1950's early 1960's bow.