i have kept every bow i've ever bought, and slowly have worked my way down to my go-to, most comfortable rig for hunting (my Retro). but lo and behold, i got a chance to do something different the other night (frog hunting), and so i pulled out the Maddog. it was the perfect combination of maneuverable, light, and dead-on that i needed, so i took it with me. it performed great! i've thought several times about selling one or more of my bows, and I always end up glad i didn't.
that doesn't help you in deciding, i guess, haha! the short answer is, "whatever does the job".