Originally posted by bamboo:
" I'm not a big fan of the complexity. Even though there are studies by one man showing that very high FOC is highly advantageous to penetration I still don't believe it. "
---what is so complex about it??
people used to believe the earth was flat too!
...then thinking men proved that wrong
purposely designing an arrow to maximize penetration is a valid endeavor--that IMO could save your bacon on a less than perfect shot--
in my book worth the effort
simply taking your normal shaft and screwing 550g on the front will likely give you very poor results and I believe the reason some still disparage the concept
a lot of real smart hunters are putting this concept to work ---me I don't believe I've ever experienced TOO MUCH penetration!!
hunt your own way--use whatever arrows you like
It's complicated because tuning arrows to EFOC changes a lot of standard principals and makes things very tricky.
For example before I got the right spined arrows for my current bow I was getting a slight stiff reading using .500 spine arrows and 125 grain points out of a 45# bow (about 44# on fingers).
With a 300 grain point they were still showing the same amount stiff yet on some shots they were showing slight weak. I've read other archers problems using very heavy points with light weight arrows.
False stiff/false weak becomes a problem and nock high is more of an issue as well since all of the weight is in the point.
Also shooting past 20 yards and they dropped really hard really fast.
I have played with EFOC and "regular" FOC and got less penetration with the EFOC arrow because of how slow that it was compared to the 125 grain point.
EFOC also does not work with natural shaft material (without a lot of work at least) since most wood arrows are naturally heavy.
Wooden arrows in the standard FOC range have worked for hunters up until the point where EFOC was invented. Now you need EFOC or else you are in trouble (kidding about that point).
For me EFOC causes weird arrow flight and a poor trajectory that want's to nose dive.
But if it works for you keep doing it.
I got into traditional archery to keep the equipment side as simple as possible and not have to use calculators or weird mathematics like algebra.
A heavy arrow with sufficient velocity will break bones and take down any animal on this planet.
The English were penetrating through steel armor using wooden arrows and they did not use EFOC to my knowledge.