Silvertip or TT ? Update !!!!! And pics added Page 5

[Steve Jr]

Ok so I have only shot Longbows for the last 10 years or so but have been shooting Trad bows since "91". I'm thinking about ordering one of these Recurves but not sure which one. I really like the one pc tip but have never shot one. I have however shot the take downs of each. So I was wondering if anyone can help me make this a easier decision. As far as spec's go I want a 58" bow and #47 @ 26". Any help on how the tip one pc shoots would be appreciated as well.

Thanks,
Steve Jr

[Biathlonman]

I'd go silvertip, no comparison for me.

[longbow fanatic 1]

I've never owned either but I can say that for resale, the Silvertip's sell very quickly. If it were my money, I would buy a ST.

[ron w]

Long wait for a Silvertip.......because of that I would lean towards the Tall Tines. Not to try to try to sway you but you might want to look at a Stalker by South Cox......nice bows and real good performers.

[Gdpolk]

I'm not sure someone can objectively claim that either are a better bow than the competition.  Silvertips seem to move a little faster and have a higher percentage of resell value currently; they also have a much longer wait time from what I'm told which may be part of the equation.  Silvertips also offer some higher end custom options such as silver inlays, scrimshaw work, relief carving on grips, etc.  Both shoot well and are well received. Another "fancier" option may be an Acadian Woods bow.  They have some really uniquely shaped riser contours and stunning inlay woodwork for some really fantastic and unique looking bows.  I'd love to have the chance to shoot or own one someday.  

I have a Tall Tines takedown longbow and am completely happy with it.  That said, I can't really honestly claim it's a better bow than any other high quality bow; its just a high quality bow that works well for me personally.

[bucknut]

I have both in Take downs. The grip is better on the TT, but the Tip is smoother. I shoot the TT better, but  shooting the Tip is a pure joy and that's what I often grab. It's all in what you want. Probably the sweetest shooting one piece bows I ever shot was a Great Plains that I shot at ETAR.

Both have very strong reputations, and it will really all come down to what you like the best, and there is no way for you to know that for sure unless you figure out a way to shoot both bows before you buy!

Good luck!

Bisch

[Steve Jr]

Thanks guys, ronw I have a Stalker Coyote FXT longbow and it is a excellent bow! I'm leaning towards the Silvertip. I have always wanted one. I still have a add that I cut out of a bow hunting magazine. It was for a new Silver Ghost and the price was a whopping $339 and signed by Paul! That had to be from about 1988/89. I'm still not sure weather to go 3 pc or 1 pc.? Anyone care to comment between those two?

Steve Jr

[KyRidgeRunner]

Never shot a silver tip, but I find it hard to imagine you wouldn't like a tall tines.  They are definitely on the top of my list.  I've owned both the recurve brain makes as well as the stickflinger.  They are lights out accurate and super smooth.  I must have a smooth bow with my elbows, and Tall Tines fits the bill.  

Good luck!

[SERGIO VENNERI]

For me it's the Silvertip and has been almost exclusively since 1984 .

[Steve Jr]

Thanks runner, my buddy has a TT Recurve and it shoots flat out to 40 yrds. They are awesome Bows for sure. I kinda feel like if I order a TT, am I still going to want a Tip? All though I was looking at the Stickflinger as well. This is not a easy decision!!

Steve Jr

[Warden609]

I have owned four TTs and currently have three Silvertips. Two takedowns and a one piece. I really like the one piece, but the takedowns have a little more mass weight. The extra weight really makes them stable at the shot. If I had to own just one recurve it would be a takedown fast flight Silvertip.

[batbow]

Order both! LOL

[MnFn]

Can't help you with the Silvertip, no experience there, but everything I hear about them screams quality.

However, if you were closer to my area I would let you shoot my 60" Tall Tines.  Especially with my 48# limbs, it is so consistent. Teamed up with 65/70 Wilderness Custom Surewoods,  I can't imagine any recurve shooting better.

For some reason I want to learn to shoot an ASL well, but the TT will be going with me to Manitoba shortly.

I don't think you could go wrong with either bow.

[Steve Jr]

I sure would like to be able to buy both! I don't think the wife would go for that          this is not going to be  easy!

Steve Jr

[Bowhunter4life]

With the two choices at hand you really can't go wrong!  Both are top quality bows that will do whatever you want them to do...  Really comes down to your personal preference...

I've owned both, and no longer own either...  just not my preference...  But like I said, not a thing wrong with either!  Do what you can to shoot both before you invest...  its worth the extra step there...  Find out for yourself which is the perfect fit for YOU!!!

[Steelhead]

Had a few of both and really liked them both.I think its a pretty close call and like what has been said.It would come down to personel preference.

The Schafer does have alot of History behind it.That stretches from the past to the present.I think its an heirloom type bow because of that.That makes it very attractive to archers.Thier Beautiful bows.

I had a 1 PC Schafer and actually like the lighter physical weight.I like its streamlined appearance as well.The aesthetics are excellent.Mine was 60".I think that's a great overall length in a recurve.Its not like holding a feathery longbow.It has nice weight.But is easy to carry and I think its still very stable and handshock is not an issue.

If you want it to be heavier you can get the diamondwood riser or heavier exotic wood.

I do like the grip on the silvertip alot!!!I think its got some unique ergonomic features.Your hand slides right into it so nicely and naturally.Hard to explain really.But you will know it when you handle it.

[Walt Francis]

The TIP

[hitmantoto]

silvertip    

[Keith Zimmerman]

GDPolk, I didn't know Dave offered Silver Inlays.  When did he start doing those?