Hi Ryan,
Welcome to traditional shooting it's addictive.
Can you tell us a little about your set up? Bow, arrow size, brace height, draw length, weight.
When I first started I had the same thing and it turns out I was shooting arrows that were way too light for my bow (carbons). I switched to heavier aluminums with 150 grain heads and my arrows flew better and bow shot quieter and less arm slap.
Grip and form have a lot to do with it but this is how I solved it.
Deadeye33