I shoot a Big Shot glove and it works just peachy for me. No problem at all with the finger stall overlays scraping my face.
Awhile back I discovered that when I'm shooting bows 60" or longer, I tend to turn my face in slightly due to the longer/different string angle, resulting in string rip on my face/nose. I can get by with a 60" bow, but this gets real bad with a 62"er.
This disappears when I'm shooting stuff 58" or shorter, as they simply fit my build & shooting style. I'm at my best with a 58" bow, but shoot stuff down to 52" w/o problems.
Possibly, this might be at least part cause of your problem...