My personal favorite glove is the American Leather's Big Shot.
I shoot somewhat heavy bows and use to shoot gloves with plastic inserts in them to help protect my fingers and when I switched over to the Big Shot it took some getting use to because I could feel the string much more than with my other glove.
For me...the Big Shot is like combining the best of both worlds. It's about as close to the same shooting characteristics of a tab as you can get with a glove yet is always on my fingers.
Your experience might be different with the Big Shot because you seem to be more acustomed to a glove that allows more sensitivity to one that provides a little more protection.
I also have to say...I use to go through a glove a year or less because of how much I shoot but my Big Shot gloves last about 4 to 5 yrs. on average for me.
Ray