Chew, "I was hoping it was just a nocking issue and lowered my nock a tad. It didn't help. Any suggestions?"
Several things can cause that biggest being the nock point, tight nocks, arrow spine, arrow nock diameter, release/bow hand to cover a few. Nock point too high will cause it but nock point too low will also. The fact you lowered it and saw no chage indicates the latter is at least part of the problem. A big rule in tuning is only change 1 thong at a time and if you make a change and don't see a change, you went the wrong way. Make changes in nock point small, 1/32" can make a big difference and 1/16" can be the difference between to far one way to too far the other..
The suggestion of weighing and spineing the shafts is a good one, if either is the slightest bit off from the old ones, any effort to make them shoot the same may be futile.....O.L.