John – Except for Fred’s personal bows, there are not many 1959 Kodiaks around with both an originally factory installed compass and quiver bushing for you to use as examples of their survivability over the past 50 years… Even for Fred’s personal bows, you need to keep in mind that they were not used much more than perhaps a single year, as he was almost always shooting the next year’s model as soon as shootable models were available.
In my collection, I have only one 1959 Kodiak that has both an original factory installed compass and quiver bushing. Floyd Eccleston bought the bow from Fred in 1959 and Floyd used it extensively for a number of years. I talked with Floyd about the bow the last time I saw him a couple of months before his death. Floyd told me it was his favorite personal bow. I would guess that you have a photograph of this bow, but may not realize that you have it as the bow is pretty well camouflaged in the photograph. Let me know if you can not locate a photograph of Floyd’s 1959 Kodiak, and I will make sure that you have a copy. Unfortunately, Floyd’s 1959 Kodiak is cracked below the grip. The cause of the crack is apparently due to both the compass and quiver bushing holes.
I have installed several quiver bushings in 1959 and 1960 Kodiaks for my personal hunting use, and have never had any problems even though the bows have endured extended soakings in rain as well as frequent temperatures well below zero. However, installing both a Compass and Quiver Bushing could provide enough weakness in the grip area for a crack, especially under hunting conditions as harsh as Michigan’s. The weather harshness in Floyd’s old hunting areas in north central Michigan and Canada are probably not much different than you find at the same time of year in south eastern Michigan, neither would be much different than here in Nebraska. Also, I would strongly suggest that any vintage bow be professionally refinished before it is used in potentially harsh hunting conditions. The survivability of 1959 Kodiaks with both a compass and a quiver bushing, may depend more on the total mass of the wood in the riser, rather than anything other than stress from drawing the bow. As I’m sure you know the size of the 1959 Kodiak grip varies greatly according to the draw weight of the bow and the fluctuations of the individual finishing. Many of the Maple Window 59s have a very narrow grip, which would likely be the least desirable candidates for adding additional holes for a compass and quiver bushing.