Trap - I hope the "59" lined strike plates you mention are true to the original color. If so I am interested in ten of them.
The Dark Brown "Reproduction Bear" 5-line strike plates that have been sold for a number of years are not even close to being true to the original color or texture. However, they are true to shape and lines.
The 1959 and 1969 Bear Catalogs did not show any strike plates on the Kodiak Specials, they were pictured only with a red feather rest (hope you made lots of red ones). Although not pictured in the catalog with a strike plate, these bows can be found with many different leather strike plates, all of which would have to be considered as “non-standard” until shown differently. I have not looked any place other than the catalogs to know if any Bear documentation from the era shows any leather strike plates as original to these bows.
The 1960 Bear Catalog shows the KSD with a pointed narrow leather strike plate, as my first post on this thread shows, the 1960 Bear Catalog image to the left of the “Clear Glass 1960 Kodiak”. I’ve owned several of these strike plates originally attached to KSD, as well as a couple on KS, but most were in poor condition.
This photograph is the best 1960 KSD original strike plate I have. Yes, I know, the feather rest is shot, and I should buy a replacement, but this bow is all original, originally attached strike plate, originally attached feather rest, and originally attached factory leather grip (grip not advertised on KSD to my knowledge). Want to leave this bow all original so don’t want to remove the strike plate to send you for use as a template for reproductions.
The “bullet shape” strike plate measures .56” wide x 1.20” long x .026” thick at the tip. It is a little thicker at the base, .034”. There is a very small slender piece of material under the center portion of the leather to serve as a thin build out. Actual color is just a shade darker then this image shows on my screen (not that you can see that far).