Last year I shot a 580-grain arrow tipped with a 125 grain G5 small game head from a 45lb bow at a squirrel that was 7 yards away and I hit this squirrel hard in his side. The arrow after hitting the squirrel dropped straight to the ground, as did the squirrel. I thought yes… my first traditional kill! When the squirrel hit the ground he flopped around a little bit, as I would expect him to do. I confidently head over to retrieve my trophy and then he jumped up and took off. :eek:
He went up into a tree and peeked around the trunk at me and I took another shot. This shot glanced off the tree and missed him completely. I looked down to nock another arrow, looked back up in the tree and saw no squirrel. I circled the tree while looking up in the tree and all the surrounding trees and saw no squirrel. So I set back against a tree a little ways from where I last saw him and I waited and watched and watched and watched. I set for 45 minutes waiting for some kind of movement or sound from him and saw and heard nothing.
After 45 minutes I went back to the tree of his last know origin and started doing circles around the tree searching the ground thinking maybe he died and fell out of the tree and I didn’t see or hear it happen. I spent another 20 minutes searching the ground and found nothing.
So to answer your question, no I wouldn’t use a blunt (rubber blunt) to hunt squirrels unless you can consistently hit a golf ball. Squirrels are tough little dudes!