MWM- For Manitoba look up Lambleys Hunts From The Heart. Run by a good guy from Nebraska, Jason Lambley. Jason is no stranger to trad hunters/hunting. His brother Brice is a regular contributor to TBM and the whole family has been involved with trad hunting/shooting for many years. Jason bought this outfit about five maybe six years ago. His moose guides are top notch guys that I have hunted with many times. If you hunt with him try and line up Larry Courville or Bobby Wodzics as your guide, both of these guys are trad shooters and moose killers/guides extrodinaire.
Valentine - sorry you don't agree but our bioligists that look after this program say and know it does. If we were to say give everyone an adult tag you would have no calves and no adults! As John mentioned his gang takes a fair number of calves, I will bet they are gun hunting that property. Big groups are the ones that take the calves the majority of times. Now since we are talking on an archery forum here, bowhunting for moose, I and no one in my party has ever had the chance to even release an arrow on a calf. 99.9% of bowhunts for moose take place during rut. We call the bull moose in, I have never ever seen a calf respond or come in to a call NEVER. No bowhunter that I know has ever had this happen so it's not a concern. The number of calves taken as I stated early is small compared to adult moose. The system works I can assure you. So again I will have to disagree with your logic on this one. Please don't take it personal!!! I'm just stating it how it is and that it works for us.