Well, I've been lurking around reading this stuff for a while, finally have post material....
My #1 hunting buddy lives out in Montana and is an old school Hill type bow guy. He's one of those great hunters you've never heard of...he's killed a bunch of stuff all over with his Hill type bows, moose, caribou, mt lion, mt goat, 15 or so elk, a giant bighorn ram, stuff in Africa etc. He's also a VERY bad influence.
I decided this summer to monkey around with a longbow a little bit, and after quite a bit of research picked up a Northern Mist Shelton used from the classifieds. It fit the bill for what I wanted - string follow/mild locator grip, but its a bit shorter than I wanted (66 inches) and a bit lighter (55 lb at my draw) however it is really a sweet shooting bow, and really spits out an arrow. The few Hill type bows I have shot a few arrows from in the past had the bad manners you hear about - this Shelton NOT SO! I was very surprised at the total lack of handshock with hunting weight arrows and the ease of shooting this bow. I've always shot high wrist recurves, and the only thing I changed with this bow was shooting low wrist...I know, I know, it ain't "Hill Style"...but I shoot this bow very accurately with the locked bow arm, deliberate draw, and solid anchor I use with my recurves. I lost 1/2 inch draw length with this bow, and get a true 29 inches out of it. I like this bow so well that 2 weeks after I received it I called Steve and put in an order for one a bit longer (68 inches) and a bit heavier (63-64 lbs) - should be done this April/May.
I packed the 55 lb Shelton along this week to Iowa to fill my doe tag. Shot her with a 620 grain arrow and a big Snuffer at 10/12 yards, complete penetration on the lung/liver shot, and she went about 150 yards.
First kill with the longbow for me. I don't think I'll convert over 100%, but I'll surely use the Hill bow part of the time. These things are addictive to shoot!
Best wishes to you all, and keep the thread moving - lots of interesting information on here!
Ryan