I laughed when I saw your pics, Rob. The biggest error I see people make with not liking Hill bows is the grip. People either can't figure them out, or can't get used to shooting with the grip that will likely work well for them. I like the grip straight, or very nearly straight so my hand doesn't collapse into looking like your photo on the left. Generally I would say a reverse handle bow will allow more of the first hand placement pic because the torque is reduced, but the arrow spine will differ from the shooter with your second hand position (right pic), where there is less torque and a cleaner arrow upon release. My hand is shaped different so it kind of looks like a mix of the two, but I can say that there is really no contact on the right side of the bow (rt handed shooter) other than my thumb wrapping around. The fat or muscle of my thumb is only pressured on the very belly of the grip, and around the shelf side. Also, very close below the shelf. The bow doesn't torque, is silent, and consistent. Also minimal vibration. Some variation of your pic on the right, although it may feel funny, will usually end up being the ticket in the long run.