Hey GingivitisKhan, I've hunted many many an hour without cologne and come up empty. Maybe it was the cologne that attracted him in the first place! Maybe I'm on to something there! Maybe I'll start hunting with cologne all the time! ;-)
Thanks to all for the nice comments. I have a question, though, as I've pondered this hunt a bit.
When I hit him, I didn't get a pass through, and as he walked away he snagged the arrow on a bush and broke it off. I retrieved most of it, but the zwickey remained in the deer. When I field dressed him I never found it though, and was quite worried that I would lose a finger in the process. How do you guys deal with field dressing a deer when you are pretty sure there's a nasty broadhead lurking somewhere within?