What about elm or ash? I know here, just north of the Catskills, it is more common than hickory.
I am seriously thinking about taking a tree or two down soon to get some staves to learn on, and for trade bait.
I have almost everything available in NY available to me. Hickory, ash, elm, cherry, locust and maple. If I do take some down and stave em up, I will let ya know.