I've used everything but spray based catalytic conversion finishes, ie. Thunderbird, etal. I've settled on Minwax Wipeon Polyurethane.
The Polycrylic, water based, does not seal effectively. I had a bunch of osage bows with 6 to 8 coats of it get caught in a rain shower at MoJam one year. When I wiped 'em down with a white towel they all bled yellow color onto the towel. Bad mojo.