I'll add a vote for the Kanati. At your draw you could go with either the 56" or 58" without a problem. The Kanati is of similar design to the Shrew bows. The grip is somewhat different, but at just over half the price of a Shrew, the Kanati would be tough to beat. Jason is also great to deal with.
I haven't shot a Shrew, but I am sure they are fine bows from all that I have read and heard.
I also agree with the others, try a bunch and see what works for you. I love my Kanati, but you may not, same with the Shrew. Before you spend hundreds of dollars on a bow, be relatively sure it is the one you want. Another excellent way to start is looking for a used bow. There are usually several to choose from here in the classifieds.