Boswell, did you use the same glue in each attempt?It looks like some of the glue stayed on the antler and some stuck to the wood.That makes me wonder if your glue is the problem.Ive used superglue gell and it worked well.For what its worth I also soak my antler in thin first.You might try a two part epoxy such as devicon 5 minuit(you can get it at Low..,W-mart ect...).The most important thing is to make sure both parts match as perfect as you can get them.Wipe both parts clean with rubbing alcohol,Let them dry,then glue with 5 min epoxy.Hope this helps.