Well you guys are goning to have to wait! Lol. Mostly because there was apparently a mixture issue with the glue. Some how, even though I read the back of the tub, I used a completely different ratio of glue to water than was called for. I thought it seemed thin when I was spreading it, but I'd never used it, so I just figured it was supposed to be that way.
The good news is that I was able to separate the two pieces without damaging either of them and once I clean them up and pull my head from wherever it was, I should be able to glue it right back up with no problems.
Ugh. I really have to learn to slow down and pay attention. I'm in a pretty serious funk about this really. I hate making mistakes that were entirely my fault AND stupid AND preventable. At least it didn't cost me anything but time I guess.