Thanks much for the advice Semo Hunter and Pat. I just realized that I left out some important information. The stave is only 2 1/8" wide on the narrow end and 2 1/2" thick, so I think I'll have to go with keeping the sapwood on. I guess I made a rookie mistake buying a stave with rings that thin. I've been scraping it carefully and so far so good, but if I can't stay on one ring, I guess I can always take the sapwood off and back it with a thin piece of hickory. Those dimensions sound great, Pat. Thanks again guys!