Cheyenne was definately the best bow I'd had in my hands...better than my Shawnee for a variety of reasons. I changed the grip slightly on the Shawnee and after switching to Bob's new Dakota (longbow) foam/carbon limbs, I don't really have a need for a recurve any more. I've sold one Cheyenne and considering selling the second. Never had a bow other than this Shawnee/Dakota make me want to sell all the rest.
Great thing about it is, you can test drive both from Bob...and I highly recommend doing so. You may find you like one better than the other for your own reasons. Either way, you are buying two of the best bows there are, imho.