I tried one by Scott T. for a while and didn't like it. It just added bulk and weight to a place where I typically use my armguard to pull the bulk out of the way. While I loved the looks and thought of it, when push came to shove it was quite impractical for hunting in my opinion. I now keep my knife either on my belt or in my pack. I use a tooled leather guard that I made for myself with no lining to keep it thinner that tucks away a jacket/shirt sleeve really well and over a large area.