I have gone several times on DIY, in fact, I would go no other way. There are a ton of horror stories about bad outfitters. The cost of one trip with an outfitter equals two without in my opinion. I have had opportunities at elk every time, many bulls. I have done nothing unusual. I find likely roadless areas as best as I can, and even mark some likely roaded areas (within reason), and then pack VERY lightly and go after it with speed scouting missions starting early and ending late. Go from location to location and just wear out some boots. BUT, when you find sign that is FRESH, or you see them etc, begin hunting and make plans to pack in more if necessary. If you are not finding FRESH sign, move on. They really stink and make a lot of sign. GET OFF the PATHS. Areas where I saw other hunters were still really good, but you will find very few elk (or elk sign) on foot paths. Just dig deep and cross terrain you would never dream you should have to. You will eventually compile many areas of promise for hunting, including on future trips. The reason the success rate is low IMO is lazy hunters. They just walk the trails and call for elk. I have called these hunters in too. Most hunters will not travel more than about 100 yds from a trail/path as they are lazy or scared to get lost. Of course, those with disabilities not included in that statement. I commonly hunt a herd of elk that hang out all day at an elevation just below a commonly used walk path, and most never even have a clue they exist...Go for it. It is physically demanding, but soooo rewarding and beautiful.