Wudstix, you are right about taking too many little bucks having a detrimental effect on the number of big bucks likely to be found on a property. Actually, I have no personal opinion about those who do or don't shoot young deer as long as a balanced herd is maintained. Shoot what you want as long as you do it legally and ethically . However, I bought my small property back in 2009 and took my first deer on it just this year, because I wanted a mature buck as the first kill there. It was an 8 pointer, not all that large a deer but a nice one. I have seen a few really big boys previously, but couldn't make the shot. I have seen big rubs, but those in these pictures are bigger than any I have seen around here. Ole Hickstick seems to have found the happy hunting ground for sure.
I sympathize with him about the big deer taken by the muzzleloader hunter. A couple of years ago, on a property just up the road, a young guy took a 12 pointer and then a 14 pointer the next weekend. I feel sure this was done over bait - before baiting was legal. Fortunately, I'm still seeing bunches of scrapes and rubs.