Rather like my Fred Eichler cordovan solid tab as it works well for me shooting 3-under. Here's some of what I like about my tab:
I can quickly and easily turn it around on my middle finger which allows me almost complete use of my right/dominant hand. Helps when pulling arrows, reaching into my hunting pack, reaching into my pocket, etc. (Try not to pick my nose
)
Goes quickly and stays well in my jacket pocket when the hunt is over. Comes out of my pocket and install quickly when needed.
I slide an arrow through the finger opening and then place the arrow with tab into my practice quiver when practice is over for the day. The tab hangs securely in vision until my next practice session. My practice quiver goes with me to archery deer camp, so my tab remains with me.
I can wear a light glove on my right hand under my tab when the MI weather turns colder. I don't find myself needing a glove often, but its comfortable when walking in/out of the woods.
I can write scores better on a 3D course when my tab is rotated.
I do carry a glove as a back-up in my hunting pack. Shoot it rather well.
Note: I generally discredit and tune-out folks when they use use words like 'always', 'never', 'best', 'worst' when telling their 'stories'. There are exceptions to 'always' and 'never' and there are folks/items better and poorer than 'best' and 'worst'. Those words tend to raise a red flag for me and cause me to question the credibility of the presented information.
Practice - Practice - Practice - Beer! Seems to work for me.