I'm not traditional bowhunter because I like to pick my nose. There's no such thing as magic leather.
Don't use a Band-Aid for corrective surgery.
Gloves and tabs are NOT release aids... again they are NOT release aids.
Are you going to be the first one I hear that says... Oh, Oh ..I lost my animal!!! If I only had used a tab.
Reports? How about reports from Hill, Bear Shultz, LeClare, Pearson, St Charlez, Pierce, Byron(shall I go on and on and on) are not credible?
One of my best friends, Mister Rob DiStefano, uses a tab. I'd put my money up against him making a shot without any tab or glove.
You use what is best for you... neither is going to make you a better shot that's up to you. And guess what don't fret if you leave your glove or tab behind if you go hunting. I promise at the moment of truth you won't know where you've got your Glover or tab on or not.