As I mentioned in another post, I usually use fletchtite platinum when I fletch carbon arrows, and NPV when I fletch aluminum arrows. But I don’t fletch aluminum arrows much these days, so I decided to use up the rest of a tube of NPV on carbon arrows so it wouldn’t go bad. The NPV seems to work fine, but I changed my mind about the fletching I had put on the arrows, and wanted to remove the feathers on a half dozen arrows that I had glued up with NPV.
I use a Zip Stick to remove feathers, and when they are fletched with fletchtite, I normally just give a nudge on the quill end of the fletching and the feather zips off like the name of the tool. With NPV, a nudge doesn’t do it, I have to give an aggressive shove like I was pushing a garden trowel into the ground, followed by a lot of scraping the get the residual glue off the shaft. Fortunately, I have defletched a lot of arrows and can do this without digging into the carbon shaft, but when I was new at this, I’m sure I would have ruined a few of these.
The bottom line is that NPV seems to stick much more permanently on carbon shafts than fletchtite, although fletchtite seems to stick adequately and I haven’t lost any feathers recently that were glued on with fletchtite. But since defletching arrows is a rare occurrence, I think I’ll stick with NPV for both carbon and aluminum in the future.