The saying, you get what you pay for, is never truer that with 3D targets….
Both Mckinze and Rinehart , make a pro or premium line, with replaceable inserts….. they are the best long term best value. They last much longer, are very realistic, and are noticeably higher quality.
Both Mckinze and Rinehart (and several non-premium brands) make a budget line of targets…. No insert, lighter foam, plastic legs, and no one really expects more than a season or two of use out of them…. Last years field point target, is this years broadhead target…. Discard,repeat…
So it really depends on your goals for a target….. I buy the best I can, for long life and a more enjoyable/realistic target on my 3D course… they just seem more fun to shoot….
One trick I have found that will make a cheap foam target last many more years, is to brush paint it, at the end of it’s first season, (you want it to soak up more paint than spraying it will) with an exterior latex house paint…… it will seal the foam, and keep it from drying out so bad….