Any type of linen phenolic works great, but micarta, g-10, and canvas phenolic works well too. The horn materials should hold up to fast flight string wear too, but I would avoid antler material.
The antler material is strong enough, and wears like iron, but…. Trying to get it to stay on the tips without popping off is tough to do in my experience. The porous nature of the material makes it hard to glue even when sealing it good, and it doesn’t bend easily without heat. And….trying to shape it perfectly to fit your limb tip is tricky. I rarely use antler material any more after replacing too many tips.
Kirk