3Rivers Archery



The Trad Gang Digital Market













Contribute to Trad Gang and Access the Classifieds!

Become a Trad Gang Sponsor!

Traditional Archery for Bowhunters






LEFT HAND BOWS CLASSIFIEDS TRAD GANG CLASSIFIEDS ACCESS RIGHT HAND BOWS CLASSIFIEDS


Author Topic: My first elk hunt  (Read 2376 times)

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
My first elk hunt
« on: December 19, 2024, 08:38:27 PM »
One of my favorite parts about hunting season is reading everyone else's hunting stories, but it doesn't seem like there have been as many posted this year as in years past. That being the case, I figure I can add one of my own from this fall and maybe coax a few other stories out by doing so.

Growing up in northern Michigan, I've been fortunate enough to spend a decent amount of time in the woods around elk, although never with a tag in my hand. Chasing bugling bulls in the fall with a call and a camera is one of my favorite activities, and I love laying in my tent at night and listening to the echoes of bugles through the timber. Like many, I've always dreamed of elk hunting, and with such poor odds of ever drawing a tag here, I decided that if I was going to elk hunt, I was going to have to get to work and make it happen somewhere else. This might be a bit long winded, and I'll do my best not to go into too much detail, but there are certain things that are a bit difficult to gloss over.

I have done a decent amount of research over the years, trying to decide which states I would want to hunt in, building points in several of them, and crunching numbers as far a draw odds, success rates, and hunter pressure. As luck would have it, my college roommate had gotten a job in Idaho, and suggested that we try and do a mid September hunt if I was able to get a tag. That sounded like a great idea to me, and after some more research, a couple of sleepless nights, lots of phone calls, and a decent amount of luck, myself and another friend from Michigan both ended up with tags in our pockets. From that point on, elk hunting was at the forefront of my mind for the majority of the year. I read and watched everything that I could, dedicated plenty of time to my calls, and spent 4-5 days a week climbing hills with a loaded pack. I even managed to squeeze in some practice with my bow here and there.

Mid September finally rolled around, and I found myself on a plane headed to Detroit, where I met up with my buddy and hopped on another plane going west. Carrying a large camo backpack through an airport isn't exactly the most inconspicuous thing in the world, and it seemed like every place we stopped at, both on the flight out and on the way home, fellow elk hunters would come up and talk, share information, and ask about our hunt. It was enjoyable, and we met a lot of great people along the way.

We landed around 2 in the afternoon, and after picking up the rental truck, we started the drive to where I wanted to begin the trip. I had bear hunted this area this past spring, and had seen a decent amount of elk sign in the form of rubs, trails, and even a fresh 5 point shed. There was no telling whether or not they would be there this year, but I figured that it was a good starting point. We met up with my buddy who lives out there, then headed up the mountain. The road was rough, and I could already see the repair bills from the rental company rolling in. We made it without issue however, and set up our first camp in a stand of pines along the road. We planned to hike up the mountain in the morning and see if we could find any sign of elk, then determine from there if we wanted to invest some time in this area, or relocate to a different spot.

As I got my gear organized, I heard a sound float down from the ridge above us. I couldn't help but smile as it came again: the sound that we had travelled 2000 miles to hear. A bull was bugling from the pines on the mountainside, and he was answered by another further down the valley. It was getting dark by this point, so we didn't have time to go after them, but we were all excited for what was to come. I had a hard time believing that we had been lucky enough to stumble into bulls right off the bat, and I had a really hard time falling asleep that night as I watched the stars overhead and listened to the bulls continue talking throughout the night.

The next morning we were up early, packed up, and hiking up the mountain well before daylight. Our plan was to sit and listen for the morning, trying to locate a bull that we could make a move on. We found a spot on an old logging road to sit and listen, and had only been there 5 minutes or so when a bugle rang out from the timber to our south. My buddies immediately got up and wanted to move closer, convinced that the bull was a ways off and over the next ridge. I believed the bull to be closer than he sounded, as I had been fooled more than once back home by a bull bugling in the hardwoods that I ended up stumbling upon since I thought he was further than he really was. We waited for a few minutes, and another bugle came, much louder than the first. We quickly decided that we were going to try to call this bull in, and as I had gotten the last stalk on our mule deer hunt the previous year, I told my buddy that he was up first and to get settled in somewhere where he could shoot. My other buddy and I moved back behind him about 50 yards, then began some cow calls. I was hesitant to bugle, as it seems like that gets overdone quite a bit, and I didn't want to get to aggressive without being able to gauge the bulls mood. My first cow call was cut off halfway through by a raspy bugle that echoed off the surrounding hills and made my hair stand on end. No matter how many times I've heard it, it never gets old, and knowing that we all had tags in our pockets made it all the more exciting.

I continued calling periodically, getting answers almost every time as the bull worked his way in. By now, he was close enough that we could hear him breaking branches as he moved, but in thick pines, we couldn't see him. The wind was perfect, blowing directly from the bull to us, and we were confident that he wouldn't get our scent. For some reason however, his bugles began getting further and further away. I don't know if he didn't like what he heard, if his cows were taking him the other direction, or if something else factored in, but there was no doubt that he was making his way further away with each bugle.

This is where my inexperience with elk hunting came into play, and after a quick discussion, we decided to try and circle around and get in front of him again by using old logging roads. With this in mind, we started down the slope to cut another road. I was last in the line, and just before I started down, I turned and looked back at where we had been set up calling, only to see a bull standing about 10 yards from where I had been set up and staring directly at me. He had come in silently from behind, and we had never even known he was there. There was nothing I could do but freeze, even though I had definitely been nailed already. He appeared to be a main frame 5x5, however, he had two matching points at the base of his G4's that were about 8 inches long and stuck straight out at 90 degree angles from the rest of his rack. I had never seen this antler configuration before on an elk, and I got a good look at it from the back as he turned and trotted back over the ridge.

We were a bit torn at this point, not knowing whether to continue after the first bull, or try and call the second one back. We opted for the first bull, since as far as we knew he wasn't spooked. It was hard to believe that if we had stayed put another 5 minutes, we could have potentially killed an elk on the very first morning of our very first elk hunt. I figured that it couldn't be that easy, and was a bit worried that that first encounter would set some unrealistic expectations for the rest of the trip.

We continued after the first bull for the rest of the morning, never catching up and listening to his bugles get fainter and fainter as the morning wore on. We stumbled across a bull moose with a cow, and it was fun to sit and listen to him grunting as he pushed her around on he opposite slope. Through my binoculars, I could see both of them gasping from running up and down the steep slopes over and over again.

The rest of the morning and early afternoon were fairly uneventful. We covered a bit more ground, and I was grateful for all the hiking I had done throughout the summer. Despite that, my legs were still fairly worn out by the time late afternoon rolled around. By now we had circled back to about 2 miles from camp, and climbed a ridge to spend the rest of the evening listening and glassing. The sunset was incredible, and we heard several bugles, although nothing close. We spotted another pair of moose on a distant hillside, and at one point heard something knock some rocks loose below us. We were never able to get a good look at what it was however, and as darkness began closing in, we hiked back to camp.

The rehydrated dinners were pretty good, and I was beat from the hiking and climbing we had done. Averaging between OnX and my buddy's watch, we determined that we had gone just under 12 miles that day. We didn't hear any bugles that night, and aside from a light rain shower around 2am, I slept like a rock.

The following morning was a very similar program, and we hiked to the top of the ridge once again to listen for bugles. It was much quieter this time around, with one faint bugle to our north, and a very fake sounding bugle to our south. We were confident that there were other hunters in that direction based on all the late night traffic heading past us as we had slept the night before, so we decided to go the opposite direction and work our way toward some of the bugles that we had heard at the dark the previous evening.

It was cool and overcast, but very comfortable weather for the most part, and we hoped that the cloudy weather would make it easier to spot elk without the sun giving everything a bit of glow. We worked along the sidehill of an old clear cut, and found several fresh tracks in the sand. It appeared to be three smaller sets of tracks, followed by a larger track that worked it's way back and forth across the road. I was fairly confident that it was a bull pushing three cows, and occasionally we could get a strong whiff of elk as we went along. We never laid eye on him however, and the only answer that our calls received were their own echoes from the surrounding hills.

Around 10, we stopped for a snack, and I glassed up three cows on a hillside just over a mile away. There was no bull with them, and my buddy reminded me to try and find elk that were on our side of the river. Shortly after that, we stopped on a point and bugled down into the valley below us. Almost immediately we got an answer, but it sounded a bit off. Not sure whether it was another hunter, or a bull with a weird bugle, we set up and did a bit of cow calling for a half hour or so, but never got another response. We concluded that was another hunter, and kept going, eventually ending up in some really big timber and climbing up to a bench that would eventually circle back to where we had started the day. After finding very little sign, and hearing several hunters calling, we decided to head back to camp and relocate to try and get away from people a bit.

Our hike out didn't yield anything promising, and around 2 we ended up back at the trucks where we packed up and headed to our next spot. This was another area that we had bear hunted in the spring, and seen over 75 elk in one evening. We knew that just because they were there in the spring didn't mean that they would be there in the fall, but it was our next best option. After an hour of driving, we arrived, only to find two other trucks already parked there. We decided to continue back in even further to try and find some undisturbed areas, but kept running into truck after truck . We saw several grouse along the way, and my buddy made a quick stalk to try and add some variety to our Mountain House dinners, but he was unsuccessful, and I sat enjoying the view as he clawed his way back up the hill after retrieving his arrow.

By now the road had become extremely rough, with large, jagged rocks sticking up everywhere. The tires on the rental were definitely not off-road tires, and I was trying to ease it along as best I could. After another 45 minutes of this, we approached the next opening that I had considered starting from. To our discouragement, there were several trucks and two wall tents already set up, with several guys standing around a bonfire. We continued on to the next spot, and couldn't believe our eyes when there were almost a dozen trucks, multiple wood piles, and three massive 5th wheel campers parked there. I couldn't imagine pulling a camper up the road that we had just come up, but evidently these guys had found a way, and I couldn't help but feel jealous of what an awesome camp they had. The head of a 4x4 bull was sitting on top of one of the firewood piles.

At this point it was almost dark, and I crossed my fingers as we approached the next area. Fortunately there were no trucks, and we pulled in to set up for the night. We didn't really plan to stick around this area with all the pressure, but as we sat around eating dinner, a bull began bugling below us in the bowl that we were parked along. He sounded really fired up, and that was enough to convince us to at least stick out for a morning and see how crowded it was going to be. It called for rain that night, so I set up my tarp and tucked under a pine tree. I don't remember much, and was out like a light.

I'll add more to this whenever I can. I can only do so much writing in one evening :biglaugh:

I'm sure some of these pictures will probably end up sideways, but hopefully not all of them!








Online Maclean

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 533
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #1 on: December 19, 2024, 09:37:44 PM »
Great story so far Trenton. Looking forward to the 2nd chapter!

I hunt elk in central Idaho, what region were you in?
Toelke, Java Man, Big Jim, Black Widow, and Centaur bows

Idaho Traditional Bowhunters
Compton Traditional Bowhunters
Backcountry Hunters and Anglers

Online Orion

  • TG HALL OF FAME
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 8310
  • Contributing Member
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #2 on: December 19, 2024, 09:56:26 PM »
 :thumbsup: :thumbsup:

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #3 on: December 20, 2024, 03:30:21 PM »
Thanks! I'll try and get some more typed up this evening.

We were in the northern Panhandle area. We had tried for something a bit further south, but those were the only tags that we were able to secure.

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #4 on: December 20, 2024, 09:38:00 PM »
Day three, I was up well before the sun and sitting on the edge of the bowl listening for any bugles. My buddies are generally a bit slow to roll out of their sleeping bags, so I had left them back at camp to get their stuff together while I headed out to start trying to locate the bull from the previous evening. The hillside below me was covered with brush that was nearly head high, as well as the occasional pine tree, and I realized that while a slope might look open from a distance, it was probably covered with brush that could almost completely conceal an elk.

As the sky started getting pink, I was joined by my buddies, and we continued glassing the bowl below us. After a few minutes, I picked out a cow and a calf, and soon spotted another lone cow feeding. There didn’t appear to be any bulls with them, and after watching for another 20 minutes, we decided to start working our way down towards the timber to hunt for the day. Far below, I noticed a large brown patch, and after looking through binoculars determined that it was a pretty active wallow. We figured that this was probably where the bull was when we could hear him the previous night, and this was reinforced soon afterwards by a bugle that came from further down the valley. We immediately started trying to make a game plan, but the wind was blowing directly from us to the bull. We decided to back out, circle down the road, and then come in on another ridge on the downwind side to try and get into position. We got moving, and to save some time, drove down about ¾ of a mile to the next ridge. To our frustration, there was another camp set up there, with boot prints going up the ridge that we had planned to take.

While we certainly could have gone in and continued with our original plan, it didn’t feel right, and we didn’t want to risk screwing up the other guys' hunt. After talking it over, we decided to check one more spot on this road and see if anyone was there, then relocate again if there were people there. As it turned out, the next two spots were all occupied, and we returned to our camp to find a quad parked right next to the truck that we had left behind. Evidently someone else hadn’t been quite as concerned about  moving in on someone as we had been, and decided to hunt the bowl as well. That was kind of the last straw, and we packed up quickly to head to a different area.

The ride back down the mountain was very scenic, although a bit frustrating, but it was public land, and we had fully expected to run into people during our hunt. Staying flexible and adapting quickly was going to be our best strategy, and we headed up another logging road, hoping to further past where we had hunted the first two days. We passed a few more camps, but eventually began to see fewer people. The country got a bit more rugged, and we followed a cow moose down the road for several hundred yards before she finally found a spot that wasn’t too steep for her to get off.

After finding a place to park, we checked the map and made a plan for our evening hunt. There were several big ridges with bowls that were similar to what we had heard the bull in the previous night, so we began hiking in to overlook some of these for the rest of the afternoon. The woods here were a bit more open, and the occasional gap through the trees would give us a glimpse into some of the grassy meadows below us. We eventually came to a large burn, and decided to set up on the edge and do a bit of calling. Our initial cow calls went unanswered, but after sending a bugle down the hillside, I was answered fairly quickly by a bull to our east. The call sounded legitimate, so we continued with some light calling over the next half hour. We got one more response, but it was a bit further away than the first. From that point on it was pretty quiet for the evening, and we hiked up to the ridge to set up camp for the evening. This was the last day that my buddy from Idaho could hunt with us, and he was going to head out at first light in the morning.

Day four started out with a bit of excitement. For starters, my phone had managed to ping off of a Montana tower at some point, and was now an hour ahead of time. When my alarm went off, I woke up and started getting ready, only for my buddy to ask why I was up at 4 already. After getting that sorted back out, I grabbed another hour of sleep. When 5 rolled around, we got up, and my one buddy headed back down the ridge to the truck, while the two of us that remained got our packs set for the day. It was just starting to get light, and I could hear my buddy making some kind of noise. He likes to sing and hum to himself, so I kind of ignored it, but it continued, and I finally walked over to see what he wanted. That’s when I was finally able to hear him hiss that there was a bear right in the brush in front of us. That got my attention, and I quickly noticed a dark blob moving up through the trees away from us about 30 yards away. I had a bear tag, so I quickly grabbed my bow and took off into the woods after it.

After going about 60 yards, it occurred to me that I had never actually confirmed that this was a black bear, and had only gotten quick glimpses of it as it moved through the trees in front of me. I was a bit conflicted on what to do, but I kept going, eventually getting a good broadside look at the bear and confirming that it was a black bear. Unfortunately, he also turned and got a good look at me at this point, then turned and took off over the ridge. I returned to camp, where we shouldered our packs and headed out.

The morning was beautiful, and we worked along the ridgetop, calling occasionally. We heard several very faint bugles, but nothing that was close enough that we could realistically do anything about. It was a bit frustrating knowing that there were bulls there, but at the same time knowing that the pack out would have been nearly impossible from a few of these locations. We hoped that the bulls might work their way up the ridges as the morning progressed in order to get the thermals to their advantage, and we also hoped that by already being on top, we’d be right in the action.

We eventually came to a peak, and seeing as we were there, we figured that we might as well climb it and see what the view was like from the top. This took us about 45 minutes, and when we arrived at the top, it was almost completely socked in with fog. We could hear one bull bugling off the backside of the peak, which dropped off nearly vertically. We tried to scheme up a way to get to that one, and after a couple of failed attempts, we decided that tempting gravity 6 miles from the truck was probably not the best idea. We ended up working around the peak, spotting several mountain goats in the process. We spent a good half hour watching them scramble around on near vertical rock walls, and running along rock ridges that didn’t seem hardly wide enough to get a hoof hold on.

After finishing up watching the goats, we worked down a lake, which had a bit of old elk sign around it. There was an old wallow next to it, which didn’t appear to be active, and we decided to try and do a bit of calling here before moving on. We got no responses, and after a half hour, we started working our way back in the direction that we had heard bulls that morning. There were several benches that we thought might hold elk, and spent the majority of the afternoon working our way through these areas. There were wallows and rubs, but we couldn’t seem to locate whatever bull had made them. We ended up sitting for the rest of the evening near the wallows, just hoping we would hear a bull bugle, but never heard anything. It had also started to rain at this point, and we weren’t really sure how rain affected elk. I figured that if the rut was happening, they wouldn’t alter their behaviour too much, but we weren’t positive.

We eventually decided to hike out at dark, and ended up running into another hunter who was coming down the same ridge that we were. His report lined up pretty well with ours, saying that the bulls that were talking were all in the bottom of the valleys. He had been hunting that area for the past 4 days without much luck, and was pulling the plug to try somewhere else. At this point we were a bit torn. I’ve always been told that you don’t leave fish to find fish, and we were certainly finding the “fish”, just nothing that was huntable. We had a discussion and decided that we would keep this spot in mind, but maybe we would return to where we had hunted the first day to see if some of the people had moved out. That area had been much more manageable, and odds were that if we heard an elk, he would be in a position that we could get to. With that plan in mind, we finished our hike through the rain, arriving back at our poor rental truck to find three of the four tires were flat. These tires certainly weren’t designed for what we were putting them through, and we were both a bit surprised they had lasted as long as they did. Fortunately we had bought a plug kit and a small air compressor, and after a half hour of patching and inflating, we had 4 round tires once again. We ran into multiple trucks on the drive out, with everyone saying the same thing. The elk weren’t moving, so they were relocating.

It took about 2 hours, but we rolled back into our camp from the first night around 10. We ate a quick dinner, set up the tarp, then called it a night. The rain on the canvas was a nice sound to fall asleep to, and I was almost out when a truck came roaring down the road, skidded to a stop next to our truck, then turned and parked at the gate that we had planned to go past in the morning. I was starting to learn that common courtesy wasn’t real popular when it came to elk spots, and I spent the next hour or two trying to decide what to do for our morning hunt.

The following morning, we woke up well before daylight to give ourselves plenty of time to hike into a different location. The truck was still parked at the gate, and the hunter jumped out and hurried up the trail as soon as he saw our lights in camp. He must have really wanted that spot.

We decided to head in the complete opposite direction and try some other valleys that all funneled down into one big gulley. The map showed an old trail that followed along the edge of one of these valleys, so we began making our way along, bushwhacking through overgrown sections, and occasionally having to take a detour around particularly thick areas. There was elk sign, although it was all fairly old, and we hadn’t heard a bugle all morning. After going a little over a mile and half, we came to an open point that gave us a good vantage point down the gulley, so we sat and glassed for a while. I noticed a cow feeding on a slope several hundred yards away, but she appeared to be all by herself. Neither my buddy or I were going to be picky on our first elk, and had we been able to, either one of us would have gladly taken a cow. However, the area that we were in was bull only, so we had to be content with just watching. She eventually fed out of sight on a seemingly open hillside, which once again reminded us how tall the brush was, and how easily an elk could hide if it wanted to.

We eventually decided to try and continue the trail that we were on, and tried following it around the head of a cut. It very quickly became apparent that this trail hadn’t been used in a while, as we ran into a completely impenetrable wall of brush and pine trees. We walked back and forth trying to find a way to breach the brush, but couldn’t find a single gap to get through. Our next idea was to try and cut directly down one side of the cut and back up the other side, intercepting the trail when it looped back. This plan worked ok going down, but we soon found ourselves in a very tight spot with no way up and out aside from the way that we had just come. The skeleton of a cow elk lay at the bottom, half consumed by a bed of moss and ferns, and I figured that she must have had the same idea as us, and starved to death trying to get out. A fate that I wasn’t completely ruling out for us as we tried to find a way through. Eventually we had to cut our losses and retreat back up the hill that we had come down, then cross another valley and climb a steep hill (with several breaks) to reach another logging road up top.

By now we were both a bit frustrated with this game of hunt and relocate, but with someone in the spot that we wanted to go, and the opposite direction being very difficult to move to, we decided a move was in order once again. I had another spot in mind that we had bear hunted that spring and seen quite a few elk in that I figured could be worth a try, so we hiked back to the truck, drove back down the mountain, crossed the river, then headed up the other side on another tight and twisty road. There was no way anyone was getting a camper up this road, and it was encouraging to not pass a single vehicle or camp on the drive in. At one point we stopped to glass a large bowl, and I was in the process of watching a large black bear feeding across the valley from us when I heard a hissing sound from behind me. I turned, only to find our rear driver’s side tire almost completely flat. It seemed as though we had found another sharp rock and punched a pretty good hole in the tire. After another road of patching and inflating, we were ready to go again, and drove until we reached the trail head that we planned to hike in. We still hadn’t seen any sign of other hunters.

After getting our packs loaded with two days worth of supplies, we started hiking, following the rocky trail along the side of the hill and enjoying the views. The bright orange mountain ash berries added some color to the mountainside, and I wondered if that’s what the bear we had watched earlier had been feeding on.

About a half mile in, I spotted a grouse sitting in the middle of the trail, and quickly waved my buddy forward. He really wanted a grouse with his bow, and he moved past me with a judo nocked and ready. I should preface this with the fact that my buddy is one of the best shots that I know with a bow on targets, but he absolutely falls apart when shooting at game. He gets more excited than anyone else that I know, and that was the case here. As the bird saw him coming, it left the trail and walked uphill in the brush, stopping at about 15 yards. As he drew back, I noticed another bird about 5 yards in front of him, and quickly got his attention and directed him to the closer target. I could already taste grouse over the fire when his arrow impacted a rock behind the grouse and about 4 inches over its back. The bird took off, landing in a tree almost directly above him and looking down. He retrieved his arrow, avoiding eye contact, relocated the first bird that was now about 20 yards away, then drew back again. The 2nd arrow took tail feathers, but nothing more, and this bird landed in a tree above us as well, seemingly none the worse for wear. I was choking back a laugh, but didn’t say anything that might come back to bite me later.

The trail continued on for another two miles, eventually ending at a fire watch tower. By now it was late afternoon, and we were ready to find a spot to sit, listen, and glass for the rest of the night. There were several ridges that looked like good vantage points, so we found one and settled in for the evening, watching the green hills slowly fade to a dark blue as the sun sank over the horizon. I spotted another bear, and found it a bit funny that while bear hunting here this spring, we had seen one bear the entire trip, and tons of elk. Now that we were elk hunting, we were seeing a lot of bears, but very few elk. There were lots of large piles of bear crap along the trail as well, some of which were large enough that it had me questioning what flavor of bear had left it.

The evening progressed with no bugles, and I found myself wondering if there was a reason that we hadn’t seen anyone else back in here. It looked like great country, but we had yet to see any elk, or even sign of them. We found a flat spot to set up camp for the night, spooking a whitetail doe in the process. She circled back several times to blow at us and bound away again. There was a full moon, and the scenery below in the moonlight was fantastic. I sat on the hillside eating my rehydrated biscuits and gravy and thinking how lucky I was to be sitting where I was and enjoying all of this.

That night I had to move several times, as it was almost like having a spotlight shown in my face as the moon progressed overhead. The doe came back several times as well, a few times coming to within a few yards of my sleeping bag before scaring the heck out of me and running off into the darkness again. We had heard no bugles, but planned to give it all of the following day and see what happened.








Offline STICKBENDER98

  • Contributing Member
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • ****
  • Posts: 1208
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #5 on: December 21, 2024, 06:33:58 PM »
 :campfire: :coffee: some pretty good reading so far, getting me excited to head back to the mountains!!!


Jason
Too many bows to list, and so many more I want to try!  Keep the wind in your face, and your broadheads sharp.

Online Maclean

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 533
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #6 on: December 21, 2024, 07:24:36 PM »
Great storytelling, great pics. Can't wait to hear how the hunt turns out.   :campfire:
Toelke, Java Man, Big Jim, Black Widow, and Centaur bows

Idaho Traditional Bowhunters
Compton Traditional Bowhunters
Backcountry Hunters and Anglers

Online durp

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1071
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #7 on: December 22, 2024, 11:54:32 PM »
Started huntin this same area in 1966...lot of changes over the years...sadly to many people and to few elk now days

Online Kirkll

  • SPONSOR
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 2693
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #8 on: December 23, 2024, 10:36:25 AM »
Come on now…. Don’t leave us hanging too long.
Big Foot Bows
Traditional Archery
[email protected]
http://bigfootbows.com/b/bows/

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #9 on: December 23, 2024, 02:11:11 PM »
I'll try and get a bit more typed up this evening. It's been a bit busy with all the Christmas activities going on.

Durp, I can certainly agree that there were a lot of guys, and not a ton of elk. My buddy and I always feel a bit guilty on these out of state hunts, as we certainly are contributing to the problem a bit. We are both unable to make it back to Idaho next fall, so there will be at least two less guys next year.

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #10 on: December 23, 2024, 03:25:09 PM »
I woke up the following morning a bit before daylight, and crawled out of my sleeping bag to sit and listen for some bugles off either side of the ridge that we were camped on. The valleys below us were filled with clouds, and gave the impression of looking at a lake that stretched out as far as I could see. The temperature was in the mid 40’s, and it was dead quiet, with little to no wind blowing.

Since the ridge was covered in thick pines, my buddy and I decided to split up for a bit, with him hiking one direction to see down the south facing slope, and myself going another to try and find a spot to see down the north facing slope. I grabbed my bow and binoculars and started working my way down the ridge, taking advantage of every small gap in the trees to look at the slope down below me, as well as the slopes on the opposite side of the valley. A pair of grouse were working their way down the ridge in front of me, but they never let me get close enough to fling an arrow. They did a pretty good job of keeping 50 yards between us.

While looking through one of these gaps, I spotted two yellow/white spots on the hill across the valley from me, just over a mile away according to the map. I sat down and tried to stabilize my binoculars as best I could, and soon determined that I was looking at two elk feeding through the brush, and both were bulls. They were working their way along the hillside, occasionally disappearing completely from view, then reappearing somewhere else a few minutes later. I wasn’t really sure how we would be able to locate them, but decided that we could circle around and come in from above, then hopefully get close enough that they might respond to some cow calls.

I made my way back to camp, and was able to flag my buddy down from a point about 200 yards away. By the time he arrived, I had camp broken down and everything packed up to go. He hadn’t seen anything, and we wasted no time getting underway to try and make a move on the two bulls. After determining that they were still on the same hillside, and trying to get a rough idea of the direction they were feeding, we began walking. The sun was just breaking over the skyline as we began our hike around the head of the valley that they were in, and we found an old logging road that we were able to get on for easier travel. The road appeared to switch back quite a bit before getting to the bottom of the valley, adding almost 3 miles of walking if we stuck with it. After looking at it for a minute or two, we determined that if we went straight downhill, we could cut off 3 miles of walking and hit the road where it circled back below us, and then we would be within a half mile of where I had last seen the bulls feeding. While the map was showing only about 400 yards of walking in the horizontal direction, it was almost a 1400 foot elevation change in the first 200 yards, and we spent the majority of the time sliding down the hill, trying to slow ourselves down as best we could. The slope was covered with thorn bushes, which made grabbing brush to try and catch ourselves just a bit hazardous.

We reached the bottom in a cloud of dust and with a few scratches, but this was meant to be an adventure as much as it was a hunt, and I couldn’t help but laugh about it. After grabbing a quick drink, we kept moving, working our way along the backside of the hill that the bulls had been on earlier. As we went, I happened to look to my right and noticed a very moose-like looking shadow standing about 200 yards away. Looking through the binos, we soon confirmed that’s what it was, and a series of grunts from the brush behind it implied that it wasn’t alone. The first moose that we had seen was a cow, and she soon took off trotting across the opening, bringing a bull in tow. I don’t know a ton about Shiras moose, but I know that they’re significantly smaller than Canadian and Alaska/Yukon moose, and the bull that came out from the brush appeared to be a very respectable one, with a wide spread, big pans, lots of points, and well developed fronts. He made the other bulls that we had seen earlier look tiny.

After watching them go, we continued on, working our way around until we were almost on the same slope that we hoped the elk were on. Not knowing where exactly they had ended up, and with it being so thick, we decided to do a little cow calling and see if that brought any responses. After getting set up, with my buddy in front ready to go, and myself about 30 yards behind, I started calling. I didn’t want to overdo it, and was only giving a few chirps every 5-10 minutes or so. This brought no response, and after 45 minutes, we decided to slowly work our way further along. By now, the hill was in the sunlight, and we figured that maybe they had shifted to the north facing slope where it was cooler. Not knowing for sure, we kept easing along until reaching the opposite hillside. By now, it was almost noon, and we decided to spend a good chunk of time at this spot, regardless of what/if anything, came to the calls.

I found a semi level spot to sit, and after making sure my buddy was set to go, did some more calling. I started out fairly conservatively, eventually working up into some louder and more frequent calls, as well as throwing in the occasional bugle. Once again, no response, and after a few hours, we met up again to brainstorm. We had quite a hike out, and figured that either they were no longer there, or just weren’t interested. The wind had swirled on us a couple of times as well, and could have given us away if they were close enough.

We decided to try and get back up to the top of the ridge that we had started on, then cross over into the next bowl and spend the evening listening again and trying to find an elk that was a bit more active. With that in mind, we had to decide how we wanted to do it. We could either hike the road back, which would be easier walking but a couple of miles distance, or we could climb the slope, hate ourselves for an hour or so, and reach the top in about 750 horizontal yards. We both agreed that straight up was the most time efficient option, and started climbing. It took us just under an hour, at times crawling on hands and knees just to get enough traction to keep from sliding down, but we eventually made it. I was glad that I had put in the time hiking all spring and summer, and felt much better than I expected.

After reaching the next bowl, we found a point to sit on, and began picking everything apart that was below us. These slopes were a bit more open, and much rockier compared to the stuff that we had hunted in all morning and afternoon, and we were hopeful that it would be easier to spot elk if they were there. As the evening progressed, we heard one bugle that was way off to our north and barely audible, but that was the only sign of elk that we came across. I spotted another really nice black bear working his way among the rocks, and decided that if he was there in the morning, I might make a move on him as I love bear meat.

As the sun set, we made some dinner and were eating when we noticed a light making its way through the trees in our direction. As it turned out, there were two other guys who had set up for the night a couple hundred yards away from us and had noticed our lights. They were local guys, and were both pretty helpful. We shared our plans with them for the morning to make sure that there was no conflict, and everyone seemed to be in agreement that there wouldn’t be any issues since we planned to go almost opposite directions.

That night the temperature dropped considerably, and there was a decent breeze blowing as I lay in my sleeping bag, watching the stars disappear and reappear through the pines waving back and forth overhead.

The following morning, we were up before the sun and began working our way down along the rim of the bowl, listening and glassing as we went. There was an old game trail that we found, which made travel through the brush significantly easier and quieter. This was our last full day of hunting, and we planned to hunt hard until noon, and if there was nothing promising, make one last move to try and find an elk. While staying mobile and being able to relocate if needed has worked well for me hunting public land at home, I wasn’t sure if that was the best elk strategy or not. Still, it was the best that we were able to come up with at the time, but hoped that we would find a reason that morning to stick around.

The wind had died down a bit at this point, but it was still plenty chilly, with frost covering everything. He hadn’t heard any bugles, and sent out a few of our own to try and get a response. Our calls echoed around the hillsides, returning unanswered every time. By now I was beginning to question our calling ability, and was thinking that they probably sounded better to me than they did to the actual elk.

As we snuck along the hillside, we came across an old elk skeleton, which had been scattered all over the place. I had heard lots of people complaining about wolves in this area, and was surprised that we hadn’t seen or heard any sign of them at all. Even looking at the bleached bones in the grass, we didn’t really know whether or not it was a wolf victim.

The rest of the morning was pretty uneventful, with the only fresh sign that we found being from moose. We hadn’t seen any sign of elk, and at noon, decided that we were going to turn around and stick with our plan of relocation. We decided that we were going to try and get back to where we had seen the bull on day 1, and just hope that nobody else was in there. With that, we began the long hike back to the truck, eventually reaching it around 3:30. We loaded everything up, refilled all the tires aside from the one that we had just patched, then bounced back down the road, passing two trucks and a side by side that were all headed up towards where we had spent the past few days. It was Friday, and I wasn’t surprised that the woods were starting to fill up a bit.

Once again we passed through town, crossed the river, and headed back up the other side of the valley, almost having a mule deer doe jump straight down on the hood of the truck in the process. As we crested the hill that led down to our first camp, I was relieved to see nobody there, as well as nobody parked at the gate. We soon had everything set to go, and after hanging up a couple of things in the trees to dry out, we began hiking back in once again. We reached the top and found a couple of logs to sit on, then settled in for the evening to watch and hopefully try and locate one more bull before the trip ended. We had been sitting for about a half hour when I noticed a yellow spot working its way out of the timber across the ravine from us, almost ¾ of a mile away. Looking closer, I realized that that spot had a decent set of antlers on it, and soon we were both studying the bull through our binos, watching as he did his best to keep 4 cows together. From what we could see, he appeared to be a big 5x5. He would run one way, head off a cow, then circle back again to try and turn back another that had made a break for it. We had been on that hillside on day 1, and knew just how steep it was where he was running back and forth. We knew that we didn’t have time to get to him before dark, so we just sat and watched as he pushed them across the hillside, eventually disappearing into the timber at the top of the hill. Soon, 4 more cows came out at the bottom, and he came barreling back out, running almost full tilt all the way down to herd the next group up. It was fun to watch, and occasionally we would watch him tip his head back, then hear the bugle several seconds later.

Eventually they had all disappeared, and the only other elk that we saw that night were two lone cows to our south. Still, we were back in the elk, and had semi-high hopes for our last morning. As the sun disappeared, we were treated to another amazing sunset, as well as another moose sighting as a cow fed out below us about 300 yards away. Between the wildlife, the scenery, and the beautiful weather, it was one of the most enjoyable evenings I have ever spent while hunting.

Back at camp that night, we mapped out the exact route that we wanted to take in order to try and get to where that bull had been headed. Since it was our last morning, we planned to be a bit more aggressive than normal, and try our best to make something happen.

Just to prove that we did actually see an elk on this trip! The grainy yellow spot in the bottom third of the picture is the 5x5.








Online Charlie Lamb

  • Administrator
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • ****
  • Posts: 8254
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #11 on: December 24, 2024, 12:31:55 PM »
Great story telling.  :thumbsup:
Hunt Sharp

Charlie

Online Trenton G.

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1522
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #12 on: December 26, 2024, 05:24:34 PM »
Thanks Charlie, I appreciate it!

The final morning of the hunt, we were up well before daylight and headed back in to the general area where we had last seen the bull the previous night. We both were feeling hopeful, as it seems that every trip we have ever gone on, we have had some sort of action on the very last day of the hunt. We were trying not to be to optimistic, but at the same time, that's what keeps us going back again and again, so it's tough to try and stifle it too much.

After getting in a mile or so, we stopped to let it get light, and to listen for a while. As darkness faded to gray light, I noticed another cow moose feeding on a slope below, looking almost pitch black as she worked her way along. Aside from that, we weren't seeing or hearing anything, and we kept slowly working our way down along an old logging road, stopping to call occasionally. It was a chilly morning, and it felt good to stand in the occasional sun patch for a few minutes and warm up. It seemed Idaho wanted to see us off right, and was giving us one more beautiful day, with bluebird skies and plenty of sunshine.

We continued winding our way through the trees, and the entire time I kept trying to suppress the nagging thought in the back of my mind that we needed to leave at noon. Time seemed to be moving a bit faster this morning, and before we knew it, it was 10:30, and we were about as far from camp as we dared get in order to walk back and get camp taken care of on time. As we stood on the bend in the logging road, we sent one more bugle echoing through the pines, and the sound had barely died off when we got a response down the slope from us, only a couple hundred yards away. There was a clear-cut below us about 400 yards away, and it sounded as though the bull was in it. We waited a few minutes, then bugled again, this time getting another response that was a bit quieter and further to our right.

Not knowing exactly what this bull was doing, and being on a potential time crunch, we decided to get aggressive, and started making our way down the hill in the bull's direction, not making too much effort to be quiet. We would break some sticks as we walked, then bugle again, to which we got a response almost every time. However, it seemed to be the same distance away every time. This continued on for almost an hour, and eventually everything went silent. No more bugles, and the last we had heard had been across the valley and on the next sidehill, which didn't leave us any time to continue after him. By this point we had reached another logging road, and it was a bit painful looking down to the furthest bend, knowing that unlike the past several days, we couldn't go see what was around the corner.

We stood for a few more minutes, sent out one more unanswered bugle, then turned and began the long walk back to camp. My pack seemed to weigh significantly more as we made our way back, and I couldn't quite wrap my mind around the fact that two days from now, we'd both be sitting at a desk, surrounded by noise and people, and this whole trip would be just another memory. Still, it had been an incredible trip, and as much as I would have liked to wrap this up with us killing a bull, that just wasn't the case this time around. We got back to the truck a bit later than intended, but that was fine, and after changing into some regular clothes, we headed back down the road. After wearing nothing but boots for a week, my shoes felt a bit foreign, and my step felt much lighter not having a pack on my back. We stopped and grabbed our first non-rehydrated meal in a week, then drove south to return some gear that my buddy had left with us after he had left. From there, we drove towards the airport, sleeping at a truck stop until about 4, when we got up, refilled the air in the tires once more, then headed to the rental return. Inside, it was loud and bright, with people walking around everywhere. A very harsh slap back to reality, but something I'd have to get used to again. The flight back to Detroit was fairly uneventful, and I was on course to be home and in bed by 9 as I boarded the last plane to get home. It was an hour flight, and due to bad weather, they ended up trying two failed landing attempts before heading back to Detroit to wait it out. I ended up getting home at 2 am, and couldn't wait to wake up in 4 ours to head to work.

I apologize that this didn't end with an elk on the ground, but I hope that you guys at least found it a bit entertaining. Just typing this up has given me the opportunity to relive a bit of this trip, and just gets me excited to go back and try again. Unfortunately due to people scheduling weddings during September, I won't be able to return this fall, but hopefully I can find something else to do instead. I'm still trying for a muley, and I would love to try for antelope as well, so maybe I can try and make one of those work. In the meantime, I'll keep flipping through pictures and reading back through my notes, thinking about hunting elk once again. I felt as though we had learned a lot on this trip, and both my buddy and I have ideas about what we would like to do differently if given the chance to go again. I certainly hope that that chance comes around someday soon.

For those of you wondering, yes, I did receive a bill in the mail about a month later for the repair of two tires on our rental truck. Evidently we patched the third one well enough that they didn't notice.


Online durp

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1071
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #13 on: December 26, 2024, 10:43:34 PM »
Great read Trenton...the panhandle is a tough place to hunt...fish and game don't bother trying to count critters, they just guesstamate

Offline KAZ

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 1402
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #14 on: December 27, 2024, 08:44:16 AM »
Well done Trenton, great story telling skills and a wonderful adventure :campfire:

Online Maclean

  • Trad Bowhunter
  • **
  • Posts: 533
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #15 on: December 27, 2024, 09:09:13 AM »
Awesome story Trenton, thanks for taking the time to share it. Elk hunting in the mountains is hard. It doesn't always work out, but it is always worth the effort.  :campfire:
Toelke, Java Man, Big Jim, Black Widow, and Centaur bows

Idaho Traditional Bowhunters
Compton Traditional Bowhunters
Backcountry Hunters and Anglers

Online cacciatore

  • Contributing Member
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • ****
  • Posts: 8334
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #16 on: December 27, 2024, 12:55:10 PM »
Thanks for sharing with us
1993 PBS Regular
Compton
CBA
CSTAS

Online kennym

  • TG HALL OF FAME
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • *****
  • Posts: 17428
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #17 on: December 27, 2024, 03:06:54 PM »
Nice story Trenton,  not every hunt ends with an elk I can tell you from experience, but it's always worth the price of admission!
Stay sharp, Kenny.

   https://www.kennysarchery.com/

Offline STICKBENDER98

  • Contributing Member
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • ****
  • Posts: 1208
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #18 on: December 27, 2024, 07:04:33 PM »
Great story Trenton!!! Successful hunts aren't measured in animals taken, but memories made!!! and it sounds like you have made many memories, with more upcoming I'm sure!!! My brother and I have made 3 trips to Colorado trying for elk out of a drop camp, we have had opportunities each year, but just couldn't close the deal, but I wouldn't trade any of those memories for anything!!!  Good luck in the future on your next adventure!!!


Jason
Too many bows to list, and so many more I want to try!  Keep the wind in your face, and your broadheads sharp.

Offline zmax44

  • Contributing Member
  • Trad Bowhunter
  • ****
  • Posts: 18
Re: My first elk hunt
« Reply #19 on: December 28, 2024, 09:12:50 AM »
Thanks for sharing your Elk hunt, felt like I was right there with you guys.
St Joe River Bows
Bear 50th Anniversary T/D.

Compton Traditional Bowhunters
Professional Bowhunters Society
Whiskey City Traditional Archers

Users currently browsing this topic:

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
 

Contact Us | Trad Gang.com © | User Agreement

Copyright 2003 thru 2024 ~ Trad Gang.com ©