Kirk,
Is there a specific draw weight that you deem I Beam is a must regardless of construction material? Excluding maybe a synthetic, G10 etc. as the main build material.
It's really more of a matter of the riser wood i'm using, and riser length. Good solid hardwood on a 17"riser has very little flex to it at 40-50# draw weights, but above 50 you will start seeing and feeling a bit of flex to it even using bubinga or ebony.... if you are using a laminated riser with accent strips, or a footing, you will add strength to the riser . But using softer woods like curly maple or walnut, anything over 50# should have an I-beam.
Some guys dont mind a bit of flex to a riser, but on softer hardwoods you can have easily have them develop compression cracks in the back of the shelf.
Using a G-10 I-beam adds mass weight to the riser too, besides zero flex, which is very desirable to many archers.
If you want a one wood riser. You can slice it up into 3 pieces and flip the 3/8" I-beam section around . A lot of the older bows were built this way in the 60's way using zebra wood. You have to look real close to see its not a solid block. I will not build a riser out of one solid block myself unless its a slender one piece long bow using good hardwood. Kirk