I like this problem!

[Dave Pagel]

I have 3 arrow combinations that all fly great and have to make a choice for my Wyoming elk hunt.  I am shooting a 60 inch, 59# @ 28 Pronghorn takedown.  I can shoot a 575 grain 2018 with a 145 grain Ace Standard upfront, a 571 grain 70-74 spine Sitka spruce with a 160 grain Journeyman upfront or a 576 grain 70-74 spine footed cedar with a 160 grain Ace Standard upfront.  I can't go wrong, but I have to make a choice and stick with it so I can shoot the combination the rest of the summer.

Dave

[leatherneck]

enie, menie, miney, mo!

[leatherneck]

Although minimal, I like the heavier point. Given all things the same, I'd pick the last one. I like the Ace head a little better.IMO

[James Wrenn]

I like number one just because it is on a 2018.  

[WildmanSC]

I like the #2 because it's footed Sitka Spruce.  I also like the Journeyman broadhead.

Bill

[Tim Fishell]

I vote for either one of the woodies!!  But that is just me!!  

[Chris Surtees]

I would go with whatever one you feel most comfortable with.

IMO they will all get the job done in the end.

Good luck on your hunt!

CS

[Steve O]

Footed Cedar with the smaller Ace.

[Lechwe]

The prettier ones!

[Big Dave]

I'd use # 2. But  I shoot Eclipes which is the same as the Journeyman. David

[Dave Pagel]

Leave it to Lechwe!  I am beginning to worry about that boy.  I see some pink crown dipped arrows with frilly feathers in his future.  It will make deer camp interesting this year.

Dave

[COMBER]

I've shot many animals with 2018's and 2016's you just can't go wrong with the durability and consistency of a 2018. I always get a dozen cedars and they fly perfectly but when I think of traveling and varing weather I always take my aluminiums.

Jake

[frassettor]

Either one of the woodies